Homosexual Behavior is More Like Consenual Incest… Will the USA have Hate Crime Laws?

When you look at the roots of homosexuality it becomes clear, especially for those of us who have come full-circle in leaving it behind, that there is a very distorted broken element of narcissism and the desire to repair the longings for connection to the same sex parent.  I must say that the Lord Jesus Christ has been very kind to me in pointing out the condition of my own emotional, relational and spiritual state in coming out of my sexual distortions and homosexuality.  This posted statement is in no way a reflection of condemnation, but one of presenting truth, compassionately as one who has struggled; even as difficult as it may be to face; the truth can set you free.  Does anyone really like looking at their own sin?  However in looking at it honestly before God there is freedom in yielding to Him, in Jesus Christ as Lord.

Dr. Gagnon has written a very compelling article in processing and reasoning out the problem of embracing of homosexuality and normalizing homosexuality to the level of race or gender.  This is what is being purposed by the United States Congress in legislating “Hate Crimes.” I agree with Dr. Gagnon’s conclusion in this article.  For me personally I see the conclusion of this legislation for revamping the USA society into a very distorted way of entering into relationships and sexuality, and thus it will continue to erode our society into characterlessness for the pleasures of being hedonistic.  We are fast becoming a society that is hostile towards Judeo-Christian laws and morality.  Please read Dr. Gagnon’s case

Why Homosexual Behavior Is More like Consensual Incest and Polyamory than Race or Gender

A Reasoned and Reasonable Case for Secular Society
Part 1: The Initial Case
by Robert A. J. Gagnon, Ph.D.
May 18, 2009

On Apr. 29 the U.S. House of Representatives passed the so-called “Local Law Enforcement Hate Crimes Prevention Act” which places “sexual orientation” and “gender identity,” “real or perceived,” alongside of “race,” “national origin,” “gender,” and “disability” as benign conditions for which society should provide special protections in federal law. Those who oppose homosexual practice are, by analogy, implicitly identified in law as discriminatory bigots, akin to racists and misogynists.

The problem is that the analogy to race and gender doesn’t work well. Race and gender are 100% heritable, absolutely immutable, and primarily non-behavioral conditions of life, and therefore, intrinsically benign. Homosexuality and transsexuality are none of these things. While there probably are some biological risk factors for some homosexual development and even transgenderism, science has failed to establish that homosexuality and transsexuality develop deterministically like race and gender. Even the Kinsey Institute has acknowledged that at least one shift in the Kinsey spectrum of 0 to 6 is the norm over the course of life for those who identity as homosexual (75%). Most importantly, unlike race and gender, homosexuality and transsexuality are in the first instance impulses to engage in behavior that is structurally discordant with embodied existence (as male and female). They are therefore not intrinsically benign conditions.

I contend that a better analogy (i.e., with more points of substantive correspondence) can be made between homosexuality and transsexuality on the one hand and polysexuality (an orientation toward multiple sexual partners) and incest (here I am thinking of an adult-committed sort) on the other hand. The latter are, after all, two other sexual behaviors that are incongruent with embodied existence that, despite such incongruence, can still be conducted as committed, caring relationships between adults. If incest and polyamory are indeed better analogues to homosexuality and transgenderism, then it is clear that placing the latter alongside race and gender as conditions worthy of special protections and benefits becomes, well, misplaced.

In making these remarks, I trust that people of faith know that it is just as wrong to hate and commit violence against persons who engage in adult-consensual relationships with close kin or with multiple partners as it is to hate persons who engage in same-sex intercourse or who otherwise attempt to override their sex or gender given at birth. It is not right to hate anyone or commit violence against anyone.

As regards a logical connection to polyamory, the limitation of the number of persons in a valid sexual union to two persons at any one time is predicated on the natural “twoness” of the sexes, “male and female” or “man and woman.” This was certainly Jesus’ view in Mark 10 and Matthew 19, where he cited “God made them male and female” as the reason for overthrowing concurrent and serial polygamy). Polyamorous behavior and homosexual behavior alike violate the natural pair constituted by the existence of two primary, complementary sexes, even when they are conducted in the context of consensual, adult-committed relationships. The very sex act itself, which accommodates only one act of penetration at a time, illustrates the essential sexual “twoness” of a sexual bond predicated on two (and only two) complementary sexes.

As regards a logical connection to incest, incestuous behavior and homosexual behavior alike violate a requisite principle of embodied otherness within embodied sameness, even when such sexual behaviors are conducted consensually between committed adults. Incest is sex between persons who are too much structurally or formally alike as regards kinship. The high risk of birth defects that attend incestuous births is the symptom of the root problem: too much identity on the level of kinship between the sexual partners. That is why society rejects incestuous sexual relationships even when it occurs between consenting adults who either cannot procreate (whether because one partner is infertile or because both partners are of the same sex) or take active birth-control precautions. The structural impossibility of births arising from homosexual intercourse is likewise not so much the problem as the symptom of the root problem: namely, too much formal or structural identity between the participants and not enough complementary otherness, here as regards sex or gender.

In Part 2 I will look at what disproportionately high rates of measurable harms associated with homosexual relationships indicate for the unnatural character of homosexual relations.

Please Read the Concluding parts of Dr. Gagnon’s article:

Part 2: What Disproportionately High Rates of Harm Mean

Part 3: The Illogic of Homosexual Unions

Part 4: Responses to Counterarguments

Robert GagnonRobert A. J. Gagnon, Ph.D. is associate professor of New Testament at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary, author of The Bible and Homosexual Practice: Texts and Hermeneutics (Abingdon Press) and co-author of Homosexuality and the Bible: Two Views (Fortress Press). His website www.robgagnon.net contains new material and updates to published work.

Comments

2 Responses to “Homosexual Behavior is More Like Consenual Incest… Will the USA have Hate Crime Laws?”

  1. Jay Barnett on June 20th, 2009 9:46 am

    Excellent article. Hate Crimes legislation is un-necessary to the pursuit of justice; it’s only purpose is to serve as an entry point for prosecution based on matters of conscience that the founders said the state should not be involved with. I will say that “free expression” is widely construed to engender all first amendment protections, so that change does not concern me. Still, it’s clear that homosexual rights activists desire to see “hate crimes” legislation evolve into “hate speech” legislation similar to what exists in Canada. “Hate Crimes” legislation seeks to limit God given rights to thought and speech, and really has little to do with either “hate” or “crimes.”

  2. Stephen on June 20th, 2009 1:46 pm

    Hey Jay! Thank you for your comment; insightful as usual. You are a man of integrity building upon God’s word and way, and not doubt it will bring help to the many who desire it. Thank you for being a culture warrior, a warrior of Truth for Jesus’ glory. You are appreciated.

  • Catagories

    Abortion (5)
    Adam & Eve (2)
    Adam Hamilton (3)
    Alan Chambers (6)
    Andrew Marin (3)
    Andy Comiskey (7)
    Another gospel (8)
    Articles (4)
    Aslan (1)
    Attitude (5)
    Audio Messages (1)
    Baptist Ministers (1)
    BGCO (2)
    Bible (14)
    Bible Study (6)
    Biblical Truth (35)
    Bill O'Reilly (1)
    Blessing (1)
    Blog (9)
    Bob Davies (1)
    Book (2)
    Brad Harrub (1)
    Brady Boyd (1)
    Bret Thompson (1)
    Brian McLaren (2)
    Bush (1)
    Camille Paglia (1)
    Carrie Prejean (3)
    Causality of Homosexuality (1)
    Chad Ahrendt (1)
    Challenge (6)
    Christians (7)
    Christmas (1)
    Church (12)
    Clark Whitten (4)
    Clarkson Family (1)
    Cloverton Music (1)
    Conference (2)
    Constitution (2)
    Constitutional Law (3)
    Counseling (1)
    Creation (2)
    Cross Examined (1)
    Dave Miller (1)
    David Barton (1)
    David Kyle Foster (3)
    David Loveless (1)
    David Ravenhill (1)
    Defiling Covenant (1)
    Democrats (14)
    Desert Stream Ministries (3)
    Devotion (7)
    Discerning (1)
    Dr. Michael Brown (2)
    Dr. Peter Jones (1)
    Economy (3)
    Education (1)
    Encouragement (15)
    End Times – Last Days (7)
    Eric Ludy (1)
    Esther (2)
    Eternal Life (3)
    Eve Tushnet (1)
    Ex-gay (17)
    Exodus International (15)
    Fair Tax (1)
    Falling Away (5)
    False Prophets (7)
    False Teaching (5)
    Family (4)
    Fasting (1)
    First Stone Ministries (13)
    Forgiveness (4)
    Fox News (3)
    Frank Turek (1)
    Freedom from Homosexuality (23)
    Freedom of Speech (9)
    Freedom Realized (2)
    G. D. Watson (1)
    Gabe Fluhrer (1)
    Gay Activists (1)
    Gay Agenda (3)
    Gay Bullies (4)
    gay Christian (4)
    Gay Gospel (15)
    Gay Marriage (23)
    Gay Political Activits (11)
    Gay Pride Parade (2)
    Gender Confusion (5)
    Gene Robinson (2)
    Genesis (2)
    GOP (1)
    Gospel of Jesus (3)
    Grace (5)
    Grace Orlando (2)
    Grateful (1)
    Great Falling Away (2)
    Greed (2)
    Grief (5)
    Hate Crime Laws (3)
    Hate Speech (12)
    Heaven (8)
    Hell (8)
    Heresy (2)
    Heterosexuality (6)
    Historical Facts (3)
    Holiness (10)
    Holy Spirit (1)
    Holy Week (1)
    Homosexual Political Agenda (19)
    Homosexuality (44)
    Homosexuals Anonymous (1)
    Hope (2)
    Hyper-Grace (5)
    Identity (10)
    IHOP (1)
    Imago Dei (6)
    Incest (1)
    Inspiring (4)
    Integrity (2)
    Intimacy with God (1)
    Intimidation (6)
    Intolerance (2)
    Iowa (2)
    Irony (7)
    Islam (1)
    Jack Taylor (1)
    James Robison (1)
    Jay Bakker (2)
    Jeff Chu (1)
    Jesus Quotes (2)
    Jesus' Words (4)
    Jihad (1)
    Jim Garlow (1)
    Jimmy Evans (1)
    Joe Biden (2)
    Joe Dallas (1)
    John Paulk (2)
    John Smid (2)
    John Wesley (1)
    Joseph Prince (1)
    Joseph Thiessen (2)
    Judgment Seat (1)
    Justice (1)
    Justin Lee (4)
    Karen Booth (1)
    Kathy Koch (1)
    Keith Green (1)
    Ken Hutcherson (1)
    Kindness (4)
    Laura Leigh Stanlake (2)
    Laurie Higgins (1)
    Law of God (4)
    Lesbianism (9)
    Letter (1)
    Lezlie Brown (1)
    LGBT (1)
    Lisa Diamond (1)
    Living Waters (1)
    Love (8)
    Loving God (22)
    Loving People (10)
    Mark Rutland (1)
    Marriage (7)
    Masculinity (1)
    Media (2)
    Mel White (2)
    Memorial (1)
    Men (1)
    Men's Rewired (1)
    Mercy (6)
    Michael Black (2)
    Michael Brown (1)
    Michelle Malkin (2)
    Miles McPherson (2)
    Miss USA (2)
    Mourning (1)
    Muslim (1)
    NARTH (2)
    NEA (1)
    Neil T. Anderson (1)
    Neill Spurgin (1)
    Neill Spurgin Coffman (1)
    New Year (1)
    News (16)
    Nick Vujicic (1)
    No Compromise (8)
    No One Is Born Gay (4)
    Obama (16)
    Oklahoma (3)
    Oklahoma City (6)
    One News Now (3)
    Oprah (2)
    Paradigm Shift (1)
    Paul Ellis (1)
    Peggy Campolo (2)
    Perverted Grace (2)
    Perverting Grace (2)
    PFOX (1)
    Picture Quotes (1)
    Politics (14)
    Potential (1)
    Prayer (2)
    Presence Church (1)
    President (1)
    Priest (1)
    Prop 8 (5)
    Propaganda (1)
    Randy Thomas (3)
    Ray Boltz (2)
    Reclaim America (1)
    Reconciliation (1)
    Reconciliation Movie (1)
    Red Flags (1)
    Republicans (8)
    Restored Hope Network (7)
    Revival (1)
    Richard Mouw (1)
    Rick Warren (1)
    Rob Bell (2)
    Robert Gagnon (8)
    Robert Morris (1)
    Rogue Judges (2)
    Rosaria Butterfield (1)
    Sally Kern (1)
    Salvation (5)
    Sam Storms (1)
    Same-Sex Marriage (3)
    Science (2)
    Sean Hannity (3)
    Seminar (1)
    Senate (1)
    Sexual Abuse (5)
    Sexual Orientation (8)
    Sexual Sin (23)
    Soren Kierkegaard (1)
    Spiritual Warfare (1)
    Stalkers (2)
    Stephen Black (8)
    Strength in Weakness (3)
    Strengthen in Weakness (1)
    Such Were Some of You (2)
    Suffering (1)
    Taxes (2)
    TEA Party (1)
    Ted Hamilton (1)
    Testimony (6)
    Texas (1)
    Thanksgiving (1)
    The Cross (5)
    The Gospel (9)
    Therapy (1)
    Tony Campolo (1)
    Tony Jones (2)
    Torah (1)
    Trolls (2)
    Truth (7)
    United States of America (2)
    Video (4)
    Voting (8)
    Wall Builders (1)
    Warning (1)
    Watchword (1)
    Wayne Drain (1)
    Wesley Hill (3)
    Wheaton College (2)
    William Blackstone (1)
    William Federer (1)
    Wolves & Sheep (1)
    Worship (2)

    WP Cumulus Flash tag cloud by Roy Tanck and Luke Morton requires Flash Player 9 or better.

  • My Twitter Feed

  • Recent Comments

Stephen Black's Facebook profile